RSS Feed for this Blog
RSS Feed for all TBA Posts

Thursday, February 3, 2011

The Boondoggle that is the NTRA Safety Alliance

If you're a follower or occasional reader of this blog, you probably know that I have been an outspoken critic of the results of the NTRA Safety and Integrity Alliance. I had been wondering where this initiative, which commenced in October 2008, was headed after Churchill Downs pulled out of the NTRA earlier in 2010, and since I hadn't heard of any tracks achieving accreditation in recent months. Well, I found out through reading the Report of the Independent Monitor released yesterday by the Washington DC law firm Akin Gump et al.

While 55 tracks aligned to show support for the Alliance back in 2008, only 25 have actually ponied up and undergone the review of the Code of Standards established. Only five (5) went through the process in 2010, which had to be a very humbling statistic for the NTRA, and none since July. The report cites "economic challenges," wherein "tracks are struggling to remain financially viable." To the credit of the Alliance, a sliding scale for fees was implemented to entice the smaller or "B" level tracks to comply. However, none of these smaller tracks (other than Finger Lakes) appears to have jumed on that train.

The proof will be in the pudding in 2011, as the initial 19-20 tracks will be up for re-accreditation as the 2-year window expires (and we know Churchill won't be one of them).

The reasons for the program not catching on or increasing in breadth isn't earth shattering:

1) The Program Has No Teeth. - There is really no motivation for tracks to participate. In essence their are no prohibitive factors for not participating. Even the independent monitor states the obvious in its recommendations to "Create Incentives for Racetracks to become Accredited." One suggested option by the monitor included "engaging state regulatory authorities to consider requiring accreditation as a condition of licensure." Good luck with that.

2) The Program is Bleeding Cash. - One look at the NTRA's 2009 Annual Report shows that it lost over $500M (or $25K/track audited) in both 2009 and 2008 (all in start-up costs, no revenue was earned per the Annual Report). Again the monitor highlighted the budget issues in its report stating there is only one full-time employee and all of the rest of the monitoring/testing is performed by outsourced industry consultants. To have a fully rigorous process, you just can't get away charging the small fees that are being charged, and now a sliding scale can only lead to lower revenues. The program is clearly bleeding.

3) Safety > Integrity. - The entire program was a knee-jerk reaction (with no dedicated funding) to the Eight Belles incident and has had almost a 90% emphasis on safety. One read of the report shows that wagering integrity, which only was introduced into the Standards Code in 2010 (See Section III of the report), attained only two paragraphs in the entire 12-page report. And you're trying to endear yourself to the horseplayer how? The monitor calls for more education of fans to the Alliance's work, recommending that "if fans understand what Alliance accreditation means, they may only want to wager on Alliance facilities." Ok, Tommy, can I get some of what you're smoking?

I'll speculate that possibly 50% of the 2009 accredited tracks sign up for the next go-round, depending on the arm-twisting that surely will occur. Has it helped safety, yes, but at what cost? Most business plans and decisions are made with a cost-benefit analysis. Are there any tangible and measurable results from the process? The "independent" report has statistics, but it provides the economic excuses for non-participation showing declines in handle, purses and race days. How about how this program has increased safety, such as reduced on-track injuries or lowered workers compensation claims experience. Just give us something that shows results. Until that happens, folks like me will continue to question the overall program.

Saturday, December 12, 2009

Where's the Beef?

I spent Thursday evening reading the Assessment by the NTRA's Independent Monitor on the first year of the NTRA Safety & Integrity Alliance. It's not a quick read or an exciting one for that matter, but I managed to get through it. It was actually a tad more exciting than the Steelers-Browns game. Now you know if you've been reading this blog, that I have been skeptical of this program from the get-go. Maybe it's because all but one track has been fully accredited. Maybe it's because they have made it more of a PR thing to stave off the wolves after the Eight Belles and Barbaro tragedies (first four tracks included the triple crown tracks). So what did we learn from the Assessment of the first year by the high powered (see: expensive) law firm of Akin Gump?

- We learned that the Accreditation process is thorough and costs way more than they are charging the tracks ($15k). However, they don't disclose what the average cost of a track audit is.

- The extent of the findings weren't earth-shattering, here are some examples: (1) some gates needed to be padded; (2) some outriders weren't wearing their helmets or safety vests; (3) one track strengthened its rule on safety helmets and vests; (4) one track stepped up a medication rule and; (5) some track vets weren't updating the Injury database.

- Thirteen tracks were accredited with two pending. (55 tracks were involved in the onset of the program).

- Akin Gump was hired to be the independent monitor and no less than four lawyers were involved with setting up the Code, monitoring accreditation results and performing onsite monitoring.

- Participation in the program is lacking in two categories: (1) It appears only the high end tracks have completed the application process and gone through the reviews; the lower end tracks have been silent and not very active in the process and (2) Funding is lacking. Several industry factions have not jumped aboard from a monetary perspective, leaving the NTRA reeling from the high cost of the program.

- The report makes several recommendations in the closing pages, summarized as follows: (1) an annual review of the code and the standards should be performed; (2) follow up "surprise" or monitoring audits should be required for accredited tracks to ascertain they are upholding accreditation and the standards; (3) the Independent Monitor should increase his presence in the audit process; (4) enhancement in communication is required to the general public and stakeholders to distribute results of the reviews; (5) form a working group to enhance participation from some of the member tracks; (6) industry needs to find a funding mechanism; and (7) expansion of the mission to handle the integrity aspect.

So the above raised the following questions and comments from the Space Station:

- How much was Akin Gump paid and how much did the entire program cost? With only $15K/track in revenue, this had to be a tremendous cost center for the NTRA (who is cutting their budget by 25% in 2010). (Of course, their 2008 Form 990 still hasn't been posted to guidestar, so we have a year to wait to even find out through public disclosure)

- What did the average audit cost?

- Where in God's name do they think they can fund this from? Who's not kicking in?

- The word "Integrity" is not addressed in the Code at all. Where is the horseplayer protected?

- The findings (a couple safety helmets and a padded gate?) seem a little light...where's the beef?

- The report talks a lot about audit rigor, but only one track "failed" (Pimlico) which if my memory is correct, was due to a technicality relating to a state law. Doesn't this seem odd?

- Can they really do anything to the lower level tracks to force their participation? Why aren't they completing the Alliance applications? Who are the lower level tracks they speak of in the Assessment?

My skepticism remains....I posted a few of these questions over at Waldrop's blog...maybe we'll hear something.....but don't hold your breath.

 

blogger templates 3 columns | Make Money Online